Skip to main content

System Center Configuration Manager 2007 OSD Comparison Matrix

Area/FeatureADS 1.1WDSMicrosoft Deployment (Lite-Touch)ConfigMgr 2007ConfigMgr 2007 with Microsoft Deployment
OS Deployment
 Architecturesx86, x64x86, x64, IA-64x86, x64x86, x64x86, x64
 Operating systemsWindows 2000 Server and Windows Server 2003Windows 2000 and laterWindows XP and laterWindows 2000 and later; WePOS & WinFLPWindows 2000 and later; WePOS & WinFLP
 Client and/or serverServer onlyClient and serverClient and serverClient and serverClient and server
 Image-based vs. setup.exeImage onlyImage only, except setup.exe  in RIS  modeImage and setup.exeImage and setup.exeImage and setup.exe
 HAL agnosticNoYes, for Vista/WS2008 and laterYes, for Vista/WS2008 and laterYes, for Vista/WS2008 and laterYes, for Vista/WS2008 and later
 Source of Configuration DataADS database (SQL)Active Directory.INI files or SQL databaseConfigMgr database (SQL)ConfigMgr database (SQL)
 Automatic generation of unattend filesNoNoYesYesYes
Image Management
 Format of imagesIMGWIM.  Also RISETUP and RIPREP in RIS modeWIMWIMWIM
 Image are interchangeable across productsNoYesYesYesYes
 Replicate images to multiple locationsNoManage externally via DFSRManage externally via DFSRYesYes
 Binary delta replicationNoManage externally via DFSRManage externally via DFSRYesYes
 Pre-stage to target computer before starting deploymentNoNoNoYesYes
 Multicast image to target computersYesYesYes, using WDSYesYes
 Bandwidth management of image xferNoYes when multicastingNoYes when pre-stagingYes when pre-staging
 Reference computer build & captureManualManualAutomated via task sequenceAutomated via task sequenceAutomated via task sequence
Device Driver Management
 Insert drivers into OS imageNoInstall fixed set of drivers via unattend.xml commandsAutomatic at deployment time based on PnP IDAutomatic at deployment time based on PnP IDAutomatic at deployment time based on PnP ID
 Insert drivers into WinPENoNoAdmin initiatedAdmin initiatedAdmin initiated
 Reporting on driver availability for devices across an organizationNoNoNoYesYes
Disk Management
 Complex repartitioning & formattingYesYesVia custom diskpart scriptingYesYes
 Deploy multiple partitions and data imagesYesNoYes for multiple partitions; no for data imagesYesYes
 Deploy and enable BitLocker configurationsNoYes, as a start-up script in the OS imageYesYesYes
 Automate setup of RAID/SAN/iSCSIYes, with vendor toolsNoYes, with vendor toolsYes, with vendor toolsYes, with vendor tools
 Virtual floppy for pre-OS hardware setupYesNoNoNoNo
Network Management
 Migrate network settingsNoNoNoYesYes
 Network connectivity assumptionsWell-connected onlyWell-connected onlyWell-connected onlyWell-connected or poor/intermittent connectionWell-connected or poor/intermittent connection
 Works for static IPs with no DHCPNoYes with bootable mediaYes, except PXEYes, except PXEYes, except PXE
 IPv4 and IPv6IPv4 onlyIPv4 onlyWorks only in IPv4 environments; can configure some IPv6 settingsIPv4 and IPv6 (except PXE)IPv4 and IPv6 (except PXE)
Deployment Models
 PXE initiatedYesYesYesYesYes
 Removable media (CD, DVD, USB) initiatedNoYesYesYesYes
 Client OS initiatedYesNoNoYesYes
 Push/pull modelPush and pullPull onlyPull onlyPush and pullPush and pull
 End user choice of image to deployNoYesYesYesYes
 Fully unattended optionYesYes after initial PXE bootNoYesYes
 Offline deployment from mediaNoNoYesYes, including CD/DVD spanningYes, including CD/DVD spanning
 Deploy to unrecognized computersYesYesYesYesYes
End-to-end process
 Task sequencingYesNoYesYesYes
 Task sequence conditions & groupsNoNoNoYesYes
 Task sequence parameterization (with variables)Per-computerNoYes, from rules using LTI databasePer-computer and per-collection with overridePer-computer and per-collection with override
 Migrate user state & settingsNoNoYesYesYes
 Install patchesNoFrom a file share for Vista/WS2008 and later only via built-in OS capabilityYes, from file shareYes, integrated with ConfigMgr Software Update ManagementYes, integrated with ConfigMgr Software Update Management
 Install applicationsYesYes, via unattend.xml  or startup scripts, from file share or baked into imageYes, from file shareYes, integrated with ConfigMgr software distYes, integrated with ConfigMgr software dist
 Install Vista/WS2008 and later language packsNoYesYesNoYes
 Install server roles (AD, File/Print, DHCP, DNS, etc.)Yes, as custom actionsYes, as start-up scriptsYesYesYes
 Obeys maintenance windowsNoNoNoYesYes
 Works in a NAP environmentNoPost-deployment actions could fail if quarantinedNoYes, task sequences wait for remediation before continuingYes, task sequences wait for remediation before continuing
 Wake-on-LAN integrationNoNoNoYesYes
Security
 Encrypts "secrets" on the networkYesNoNoYesYes
 Encrypts "secrets" on the target computerYesNoNoYes, except during Vista setup phaseYes, except during Vista setup phase
 Strong authorization of target computerYesNoNoYes, except for PXEYes, except for PXE
 Encrypts user state during migrationNoNoNoYesYes
 Encrypts images on the networkYesNoNoYesYes
 Password protect deployment mediaNoNoNoYesYes
Reporting
 Aggregate status of all deploymentsYesVia Crimson eventsYes with OpsMgrYesYes
 Detailed status of individual computersYesVia Crimson eventsYes with OpsMgrYesYes
Admin UI
 Central monitoring of deploymentsYesOnly for multicast transmissionsNoYesYes
 Task sequence editorLimitedNoYesYesYes
 Sophisticated targetingNoNoNoYesYes
 Multiple simultaneous IT adminsYesYesNoYesYes
 User access controlsYesNoNoYesYes
 ScriptableYes, with WMIPartial via COM+Scriptable .Net data layerYes, with WMIYes, with WMI
 LocalizedNoYes, to Windows Server languagesAs funded by country subsYes, to ConfigMgr server languagesYes
 Framework technologyMMC 2.0MMC 2.0MMC 3.0MMC 3.0MMC 3.0